The No Surprises Act: A Costly Arbitration Experiment That Congress Must Fix

It’s time to stop the NSA arbitration bleeding

I have written numerous blogs and newsfeeds about what I believe is one of the most significant and overlooked problems in American healthcare: the arbitration process created under the No Surprises Act (NSA). What was intended to protect consumers from unexpected medical bills has evolved into a costly payment mechanism that is driving up healthcare spending, distorting provider incentives, and adding yet another layer of pressure to an already struggling employer-sponsored insurance market.

The numbers are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

An arbitration process increasingly tilted toward a small subset of providers

The federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process uses what is commonly called baseball-style arbitration. Both the provider and insurer submit an offer, and the arbitrator selects one. He or she cannot go in the middle.

The problem is that providers are winning approximately 85% of disputes for all of 2025, with the rate reaching 88% in the first half of that year. More troubling, the awards can be extraordinarily high. Georgetown researchers found that providers prevailing in 2025 received a median award of 445% of the qualifying payment amount (QPA), which is intended to represent the median in-network rate. In other words, the typical winning provider award was more than four times that benchmark.

The costs are staggering. A November 2026 analysis by the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) estimates that the IDR process added $8.39 billion to employer health plan costs in 2025 alone. That represents approximately 63 cents for every $100 spent by employer-sponsored plans. Even after excluding unusually high awards, the estimated additional costs remained above $8 billion.

Georgetown researchers have estimated that the broader IDR process generated more than $22.4 billion in additional spending over four years.

It is important to note that it is actually a small number of providers that are taking advantage of the IDR process.

The consequences extend well beyond individual disputes

There is a much larger economic problem here. When providers can potentially receive several times the prevailing in-network rate through arbitration, the incentive to negotiate reasonable in-network contracts diminishes. Why accept a negotiated rate when remaining out of network and pursuing arbitration can produce substantially greater payments?

This creates a distorted marketplace. Employers ultimately bear much of the financial burden, particularly in self-funded arrangements. Those costs eventually find their way into higher premiums, greater employee cost-sharing, and reduced benefits.

Employer healthcare costs are already increasing at unsustainable rates. WTW projects an 11.1% increase in employer healthcare costs for 2027 before plan changes and 9.7% after adjustments. IDR is not responsible for all these increases, but it is an unnecessary contributor to a problem employers can scarcely afford.

Congress and the administration must acknowledge the mistake

I was critical of this legislation when it was being developed. The baseball-style arbitration approach had already demonstrated problems in states such as New York and New Jersey. I argued that importing this model into federal law would create incentives for providers to pursue arbitration and drive payments higher.

Unfortunately, those concerns were not adequately addressed.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projected that the legislation would reduce premiums by approximately 1% and produce $17 billion in deficit reduction over 2021–2030. Those projections assumed that lower provider payments would generate savings. CBO has since acknowledged that administrative costs exceeded expectations and that arbitration outcomes could ultimately push prices higher. The original expectations for arbitration volume were also dramatically underestimated.

The Trump administration has begun taking action on program integrity. In November, federal officials denied recertification to two IDR entities that failed to meet minimum performance standards. This is an important accountability step. More oversight and meaningful consequences for entities that fail to administer a fair process are essential.

There may finally be an opportunity for reform

There is some encouraging news from Congress. Senator Bill Cassidy’s health policy adviser, Romney Gripado, recently indicated that Cassidy intends to release legislation addressing the shortcomings of the NSA. The proposed approach would strengthen oversight, improve transparency, restore accountability, protect employers from unnecessary costs, and encourage providers to return to in-network arrangements.

This is an area ripe for bipartisan compromise.

I believe the starting point should be straightforward: fairness and equity should dictate that the median negotiated in-network fee for the same service in the same geographic market be the presumptive payment benchmark. Adjustments could be made for legitimate differences in complexity, acuity, and other relevant circumstances. But the burden should be on a party seeking a substantial departure from that benchmark to demonstrate why it is justified.

Patients must remain protected from surprise medical bills. That was the original purpose of the legislation, and it remains an important consumer protection. But protecting patients does not require creating a payment system that rewards extraordinarily high out-of-network reimbursements.

Congress created this problem. Congress has an obligation to fix it. The affordability crisis is real, employers are struggling, and employees are increasingly paying the price.

The No Surprises Act should not become another example of well-intentioned legislation producing exactly the opposite of its intended economic result. Today, Americans are free from surprise bills for the most part. But their pockets are still empty due to aggressive healthcare cost increases each year. IDR contributes to the problem.

#nsa #nosurprisesact #transparency #healthcare #coverage #employercoverage

— Marc S. Ryan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Available Now

$30.00