
The No Surprises Act: A Costly Arbitration Experiment That Congress Must Fix
It’s time to stop the NSA arbitration bleeding I have written numerous blogs and newsfeeds about what I believe is one of the most significant and overlooked problems in American healthcare: the arbitration process created under the No Surprises Act (NSA). What was intended to protect consumers from unexpected medical bills has evolved into a costly payment mechanism that is driving up healthcare spending, distorting provider incentives, and adding yet another layer of pressure to an already struggling employer-sponsored insurance market. The numbers are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. An arbitration process increasingly tilted toward a small subset of providers The federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process uses what is commonly called baseball-style arbitration. Both the provider and insurer submit an offer, and the arbitrator selects one. He or she cannot go in the middle. The problem is that providers are winning approximately 85% of disputes for all of 2025,









