Trump And Johnson Silent On Reforming Employer Healthcare Deductibility
Donald Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-LA, are not saying whether they support the House Republican Study Committee’s (RSC) proposals to potentially cap the tax exclusion for employer-sponsored coverage. Employers can deduct premiums from federal and payroll taxes. Workers’ shares of premiums are also exempt from income taxes. These tax breaks cost about $300 billion combined a year today.
The RSC is a conservative policy caucus within the House GOP members. Its proposal on employer healthcare tax deductibility is unclear, but its budget document certainly infers the deduction may be limited and it also calls for equalizing individual and employer deductibility. There are a few ways to limit the tax deduction, either capping what an employer can take outright or taxing individuals over certain amounts individually.
Opponents argue the unfettered deduction drives up healthcare costs. To some degree this may be true, but capping it would likely increase employer costs dramatically or transfer it to workers. The RSC also does not instill confidence that individual purchasing, which it clearly favors, would in fact mean robust and comprehensive coverage for all. With its other healthcare proposals, coverage would dramatically change and likely lead to fallout.
America is the only developed country with an employer-based healthcare system as its base, which puts businesses at a major competitive disadvantage compared with other nations. And remember, this is a tax deduction and not a credit – so business pays the lion’s share of costs and not the federal government.
I still believe a refined Cadillac tax, passed as part of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and later repealed, is the best way to rein in healthcare costs without hurting overall tax deductibility of healthcare costs. Unless there is something truly better that gets us to affordable universal access, the tax deduction for employer-sponsored insurance has to stay in place as it drives overall coverage in America.
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) says a cap could save between $500 billion and $900 billion over a decade. A Republican Congress and a President Trump could take some piece of employer insurance deductibility to pay for the extension of the Trump tax cuts.
(Article may require a subscription.)
#employercoverage #healthcare
https://insidehealthpolicy.com/daily-news/trump-johnson-silent-tax-treatment-employer-coverage