
More Clover Lawsuit Fallout: The Balkanization of Star Ratings
More lawsuits and more Star rating scenarios in play Ok, so this is my fifth blog on the fallout from the Clover lawsuit decision, but continuing the saga is certainly merited. The Tukey outlier and guardrail decision in 2024 for SY 2024 Star Ratings certainly was defining in that plans won their point that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) was blatantly ignoring the regulatory process. Yet the Clover decision now appears to be going even farther in that Clover Health has exposed the fact that the Stars program as we have known it was not based in statute. More so, it now has created program uncertainty and the real chance that there may be no solid Stars foundation on which to calculate quality outcomes for the near future. Indeed, I am now characterizing what is occurring as the “balkanization of Star Ratings.” Let’s back up and give




