
October 23, 2026
Centene Files Stars 2027 Lawsuit We had four 2026 Stars measure lawsuits — Clover, Elevance, Scan, and Alignment.We now have three 2027 Stars measure lawsuits — Alignment, Healthfirst, and Centene. Centene has become the latest insurer to sue over its Medicare Advantage 2027 Star ratings. Centene has filed in the same Georgia southern district as Clover and Elevance did in SY 2026. Centene argues that CMS violated the Administrative Procedure Act in determining its 2027 ratings. Centene says that CMS ran afoul of “core statutory safeguards” in deploying 17 measures. Because of that, Centene says its 4 Star and greater enrollment dropped from 18% to 9% and cost the company $448 million in quality bonus payments for payment year 2028. Centene’s lawsuit parallels the Clover one. Most importantly, Centene makes this fabulous point: CMS tacitly admits its methodology is wrong because it applied a different calculation to Clover in both
